I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA
Previous threads we've done: https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=proberts.
What are my realistic options for starting a company without giving up my current job?
I’ll need to figure out potential IP issues, seems sticky because I have a bunch of patents at $dayjob.
I guess that limits me to something completely unrelated?
If I understand correctly, PERM asks for all experience to be from a previous role. With the advent of AI over last few years, if I have worked at my current employer for a while and use AI a lot, I still cannot call it “previous experience “. This also relates to how particular skills are to be acquired and claimed when, apparently, AI does it for you often.
How do PERM applications need to evolve given current evolution in tech sector with AI?
I know a case where a person has waited for 4 years. I haven't heard of longer cases. So I'd assume 3-4 years.
Depending on the nationality, there might be some relevant local chats with more information, statistics, U.S. court cases, specialized attorneys...
In your experience, are companies still doing H1Bs? Is it perceived as too risky to attempt now, or are people trying to rush H1Bs while the fees are "low"?
Gasp.
The fiction that there are tons of qualified Americans who are boxed out of tech is persistent but doesn't make any sense when you look at how high tech salaries are and how much real wages in the field have grown in the US. It would make no sense for that to happen if the labor pool for that field was large enough to absorb all the demand
Additionally, MS for one example wouldn’t let go of US workers while at the exact time applying for more H1Bs.
Is the process frozen for everyone, or is this an exception? Is there anything he can do?
Thanks, and have a great rest of your day!
The questions was this last time and I'll just copy it :)
"I was counted against the H1-B cap in 2017 and worked for about 3 months before I left the states.
Would I be able to use the rest of my time now if I were to get a job in the states?"
I know that TN appears to be the most straightforward, or O-1A; but they require "sponsorship". But people have told me about EB-1A, E-2 (investing in a US startup) or O-1A.
The chicken-and-egg problem is that currently most US companies filter on the ATS question of "do you have a Visa to work here?", so it's never possible to even get a "foot" in the door to talk about options.
This is a question I already asked to LLMs, but I would be happy to read the nuances of real life; what are the options? is there a real path?
Not sure how to privately contact you to follow up, so if you shoot me an email at. omar@baqueiro.com it would be lovely.
- Upton Sinclair
How is that relevant or useful information? You know full well that the H1Bs aren’t starting tech companies.
However, "Do you ever feel remorse for what you are doing" crosses into personal attack, and that is not allowed in this thread or any other on HN. We all have plenty to feel remorse about.
If you have a substantive point, you can make it respectfully and thoughtfully; if not, there's no need to post.
Consider using your platform to help Eva Yi Xie, a Princeton neuroscience PhD student recently detained by ICE.
MAYBE relevant information other readers might want to know.
Remind me which countries allow you stay when visa expires?
And that was always against the letter of the law. That was a policy decision and it is no longer the policy decision.
She came here on a visa and decided to overstay. No other country on earth allows this.
Also, she is claiming asylum from China… the worlds other super power. Not Haiti or Libya. And she has visited since.
Admit the truth instead of dancing around it. She tried to break the law and was caught. End of story.
> According to Ms. Xie’s lawyers, because her asylum application has not yet been approved and her previous visa is expired, ICE agents were alerted when she passed through an airport security checkpoint.
— https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/20/science/chinese-scientist...
"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it."
It's easily provable. There's one country from which the majority of immigrants are H1Bs: India. Can't use China bc there are many Chinese immigrants from long ago who didn't come as H1Bs (and who made up various Chinatowns in the US).
Indian Americans are the richest ethnicity in the US and the most likely ethnicity to be H1B holders or have arrived here through H1B work (Father's employment etc.)
If there were tons of qualified Americans who were being suppressed by H1Bs, then this demographic wouldn't be so wealthy.
At the same time, real wages for tech workers in the US have risen substantially and outpaced inflation substantially. Again if we were in a scenario where there was lots of available, qualified labor, this wouldn't happen. It especially wouldn't happen if the point of H1B hiring by tech companies was to suppress tech worker wages.
Now all those things together are puzzling: the income H1Bs earn, the rising real wages of the fields where H1Bs are employed. These don't make sense if there is a large pool of qualified applicants no company will hire.
Those data points all make sense if there isn't actually a large domestic pool of qualified talent. Then suddenly everything lines up really well. Bc H1bs are artificially limited, the talent pool would be artificially limited as well, which would drive up wages, much like we are seeing.
I hired a law firm months ago and honestly the prospects don't look very good. They have been claiming the process became much more strict and denial rates have never been higher :/
Have initial requests/emails gotten easier? Has your time taken per onboarding gotten shorter?
Quick rundown: I have a MS CS from the University of Hawaii and a BSC from ETH Zurich, Switzerland. I've been in the US on E-2 since 2022 but E-2 renewal doesn't look too good. No patents, awards or press coverage, no publications in the last 10y. No independent letter of recommendations.
Maybe a side question too, how much can I rely on Claude-as-a-lawyer and process guide? Has anyone been successful with that lately?
Thanks for doing this. Appreciate the chance to ask the question.
My question then is how such changes would affect the process of ensuring an organization can otherwise intentionally hire someone requiring a visa. What do you think, in your professional experience?
Why would a patriotic American employer avoid qualified applicants? Should we tighten the laws for American employers and have increased government oversight of their hiring processes?
Your H1B visa won't last that long.
I'm a long-time Canadian TN Visa holder who has been married to an American the last three years and have not pursued a green card.
I'm thinking about applying for the marriage green card now and am wondering if you feel that any local lawyer is able to handle the process or if there are any additional considerations given the macro climate.
Also, is continually renovating the visa (5+ years) doable or there's a unwritten limit? Thanks!
I'm at an R1 university, and my NIW was rejected with them saying that Cancer research etc isn't nationally relevant, and I'm closing to maxing my duration on my H1. We just got my EB1B submitted yesterday on Premium processing, so this is extra stressful.
No one knows what the future holds and what new shenanigans may happen
I truly know nothing of the process, being born here. Can you please share your opinion on the matter of our contrary takes (the degree of threat post-green card)? Are you aware of any cases where someone has been snatched and deported, despite having one, outside of criminal cases? Have you knowledge of cases of ICE grabbing people taking a citizenship test (she’ll be eligible soon)? How rational is my concern, in your estimation?
Thank you for conducting this AMA and sharing your time with us.
0. https://www.techdirt.com/2026/11/17/pissed-off-judge-orders-...
I think you are mentally in the right place and she is attributing to the administration too much good faith.
Facts:
(1) the Trump Admin is actively trying to claw back citizenship (which is a higher hurdle than green card) from anyone they can find a plausible legal excuse to. Usually this means a material misrepresentation (eg. A lie) on any immigration / naturalization related form or interview.
(2) the admin is speeding up immigration court proceedings, including changing dates without the normal notice (which causes well intentioned immigrants to miss a court date and be subject to deportation). Many of the detainments, arrests, and deportations ("abductions") you read about on the news are in relation to this.
(3) Anybody in the immigration process who may have missed a court date / interview, or had an arrest which was subsequently dropped / acquitted (usually during a prior administration) is becoming a target for deportation. Even green card holders who think they have "already dealt with" whatever bureaucratic issue they had are at risk. These issues can be used as an excuse to claw back a green card.
(4) Refugees are at risk. The various refugee programs that Congress passed in statute are considered illegitimate by many people in the current administration.
There's not much you can do to prevent a detainment, but you should be mentally prepared that it could happen and make some preparations[1] in case it does. Even if it never happens, this is just smart planning (like saving for retirement or writing your will).
[1] https://www.immigrantdefenseproject.org/wp-content/uploads/E...
I'm seeing a lot of news of people with legal status and no criminal records being arrested and detained (ranging from citizens, to people with pending AOS, to people who entered legally and have bona fide asylum cases) and wondering if there is likely to be any change in the near future.
Do you foresee that trend continuing and why?
Wondering if you think administration/attitude change is worth waiting or are my odds of success basically independent of overall trend?
As software engineers and people residing in USA, what we can do about this and how can we help to fix this, for ourselves and for others?
https://checkvisaslots.com/ was a lifeline for me when trying to find slots. It alerts you when slots are available by requiring everyone who has the extension to submit screenshots of the usvisascheduling page.
They seem to have revamped the page to make it look a lot more commercial than before, but it is legitimate. I think the best thing we can do is lean more into these community-based solutions or implement our own.
I’m curious what the biggest changes you’ve see in policy (or current interpretation of it) during the last ~year are that you feel aren’t as discussed as the more obvious/popular ones in these kinds of threads?