Ask HN: Any actual balanced reviews of GTA 6?
Here's his review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gRkH7iPIXrA
Two things you should know - the review has no spoilers and the press and streamers had the game for roughly 3 weeks with an embargo on communications and a further embargo on spoilers I think beyond launch date. They gave them enough time to play the story through.
The mechanics are different than GTA5 and more realistic. An example, you cannot carry an arsenal of weapons everywhere you go. In GTA5 you could "carry" multiple long rifles, smgs, pistols, rocket launcher, baseball bat, etc. all at once.
I'm sure there's other things that are more realistic and many things that are ridiculous, it is a fictional video game made for entertainment purposes after all.
Is there any player-hostile nonsense? For example, does it require an account? Is it playable offline? Does it have microtransactions? Does it have ads? Is there already DLC they paywalled off to take more of our money? Is there an in-game currency you can buy with real money? Does it feel like the retail price ($100) gave you a complete single player game or is it more like a MMO/live service game?
For GTA 6 I definitely had to "sign" ToS and such before getting in. Didn't read a lick of it, maybe it shadow created a Rockstar account for me?
So far in my ~2 hrs I haven't seen any of that. I also haven't even looked at the store menu at all because I could care less what they're selling. I'm sure some of those things are coming. There is a GTA+ thing I saw as a purchase option ($8/mo) which I avoided. That might be how they do those things, like an MMO should, with monthly subscriptions.
Anyways I feel like I bought a complete single player game since I generally ignore all that stuff when I play games.
Not to be glib, but a lot of people that've played rockstar games before can make a purchase decision by hearing "another gta, stronger RDR temperament than 5, gorgeous but 20-30fps."
Prior GTA games kind of gave me meaningless chaos vibes and I never really played them. But this one doesn't feel meaningless - it's funny, romantic, and fun to play together. Mechanics-wise, the best I can describe it is a crossover of cops and robbers, The Sims, and Animal Crossing.
For the fans of earlier GTA games, this should tell you everything you must know about the game. I refunded it after 2.5hrs of gameplay.
I think one cool thing about it is it seems to be adaptable to your chosen play style. I know people who don't want to do any of the house management/relationship stuff and just want to mostly focus on running around doing crime, and they get to do that too. Turns out we both seem to enjoy these more chill aspects of it between action missions so we ended up doing more of those.
I care about escaping from life when playing the game, RDR2 did a good job this i feel is much better
I had no interest in the release of GTA 6, but people have been talking to me about it over the last couple of weeks so this week I watched some game play to see what the fuss was about, and I've been pleasantly surprised at how good it looks and how interested I am in it.
I guess the characters seem more relatable to me and the game seems less mindlessly violent than how I remember of past GTA games?
However, I've noticed a lot of people who used to like GTA seem to be having an opposite reaction to me, which I think is interesting.
Still not sure I care enough to play it, but I don't feel the same visceral dislike of what I've seen so far of GTA 6 as I have had for past versions.