Ask HN: Where do you see Software in 5 years?
For context, I'm a L4 SWE that has more or less say 5-10 yrs of exp.
I've enjoyed my work throughout my career, AI makes me ship more, much more than I could do 3 years ago. I feel I use it well and it translates into really good software.
That said, what do you think happens in years to come with the Software industry in general? Do you think we'll go through a massive erosion of jobs? What's your perspective on that?
I'm asking because I honestly don't know what to do: I can try to always keep up to date with newest technologies, best practices, but I'm only me; if the demand for SWEs and jobs falls to the floor, I'm not sure I'll always get a place at the table (i.e. land a job) and I'm wondering whether I should try to do something else in some other industry. It feels weird to be in a good position in life and still constantly worry about it getting worse.
if you're anxious about job security, standing out in your career is generally not specific to the industry you are in.
Doomer perspective I know. Kind of representative to my mental health.
Many people are building their own all-in-one apps that will replace everything big tech offers. This restores privacy and you won't be missing anything.
Silo 1 - This will be employers strongly forcing AI for most task completion. This will be most large corporate employers and most start ups. There will be little to no working knowledge of the internals of large applications and these employers will bleed money on outside consultants to occasionally provide manual maintenance and security hot fixes. Everything will continue to look good from the outside, but really its a messy house of cards.
Silo 2 - This will be institutional shops of skilled experts. Game companies that own internally developed rendering engines, kernel developers, independent open source, and systems architects come to mind. These will be people that might occasionally dabble in AI for various things, but they manually modify their code. These are experts who do not gain productivity by offloading their greatest challenges to AI.
Silo 3 - The consulting class. This is where the money will be. Technology design firms already do most of this, but the problems these consultants solve for their clients will be greater and the clients will be less capable. These people will explode in demand, but supply will likely remain unchanged, because experts are hard to grow and the corporate world won't produce them.
---
I also predict the job recruitment industry will struggle as demand for talent stratifies, because software as an industry struggles to identify talent. This problem will remain unsolved until something catastrophic happens and most employers need to simultaneously unload liability in ways they are currently forced to accept it internally. Fear of bankruptcy, loss of money, and complete destruction of business are not strong enough motivators to move the needle on this.
On the other hand, I see a trend of bypassing standard user interfaces. We have chats, voice communication is being developed, so in the future (if we still have it), we'll only need a few applications to work.
In 5 years We will have far passed the ability and need to review code. We will have phenomenal AI reviews to do that.
Existing tools, systems, frameworks and such just won't matter, would just slow down AI. Replacing complete vertical system silos will be done in a single, crazy step, efficient to run, secured by an awesome security AI.
I recently retired after working in software development from 1975 to 2025 encompassing punch cards to AI.
It's interesting to me that you consider the software that you're currently using to be so easily replaced. I read through your comment history just now and the only software you've mentioned using is TurboTax (which doesn't surprise me given the state of "Hacker" News in 2026). Would you mind posting a link your dotfiles so we can see what software you're currently using? Thanks.
Hah, recently I've seen a number of comments along the lines of "yeah everything is a blackbox now, and that's good actually, deal with it". I can hardly think of any statement that could be more antithetical to the hacker mindset orginating back at the TMRC and such.
Everything's moving very fast now. We will see traditional boundaries between software components changing very quickly.
But i was there when gpt2 and 3 came out i even had early access and I learned how it worked and I can say one thing companies still need software engineers as long as LLMs themselves exists, this isn't end all and be all they are trying to force this idea into existence AI by this time should have already replaced all coders but it isn't because giant corporations are trying to force scaling instead of finding a way to make them more intelligent in a meaningful way.
The onramp for coding becoming easier means non-tech people finally have a cheaper way to try out business ideas for domains they're experts in. Many of those will succeed and will need to hire developers, massively increasing the demand.
Coding becoming easier means many more people will jump in, reducing wages rapidly. While there might be some work available, it'll mostly be low paid.
Now that one person can do the job of 5, 4/5 will be laid off and we'll all struggle to get work.
Now that one person can do the job of 5, AND there will be an increased demand for more developers from more businesses popping up, we'll be paid a hell of a lot more for the value we can generate.
The speed of code generation is going to catch up to us in the form of tech debt, and we'll see the outcome of that in 12 months as codebase development slows to a halt and AI can't deal with it. We'll be swamped with work.
AI will continue to develop at a rapid pace and take over all white-collar work and the world will change as we know it.
Take your pick. I don't know.
Even if we don't get the shortage of developers, AI may make it easier to capture the value, because it makes it easier to start your own company.
A return to personal computing as it existed in the early 80s, where owning a computer meant writing your own software for it, with exceptions.
Alternatively, hardware scarcity meaning everything is forced to the cloud.
But I expect that SWEs will become more like civil engineers. Right now, the laborers are also the engineers. In the future, they'll be separated.
There's standards. We're just not following or aware of them because it was impractical. RFC 9078 on sending a thumbs up in an email. RFC 6531 lets you make an email address consisting of emojis. RFC 5322 on writing (nested) comments in the email address.
Then there's accessibility violations like re-entering passwords, lack of alternatives to drag and drop, toasts that aren't handled by screen readers, image carousels that can't be paused, relying only on red color to convey error.
We'll probably be communicating globally in a similar form to RFCs instead of open source code, just working out why/what/how and what goes wrong.
Short answer for anxiety: learn about the business your software skills serve and align with domain subject matter experts.
As "AI" slop eats up more and more of critical software and even tries to make it's way into hardware design, we'll start seeing more and more subtle nearly impossible to track errors: calculator gives 2+2 equals 5 why? Is it calculator? Underlying math lib? Compiler? OS kernel? RAM? CPU?
The thing is that we are too used to have some systems well engineered and rock-solid that we don't think about them. When javascript or python program fails, we don't blame the runtime, since we expect it to be stable. But can you expect vibe-coded slop to be stable?
And why would you even need a computer that cannot compute?
And so it goes, more and more specific desires, with fewer and fewer people that want those specific desires.
So one possible future is that we move further out on the fractal. More people get what they want, even if not many people want the same thing. This means that the customizations have to take less software engineer time, because a customer base of just a few people can't pay very much.
In that future, the key activity is going to be efficiently finding small groups of users, learning what they actually want, and then generating that.
In 5 years, I think there are 2 scenarios: - either everything will be devoured and serviced by AI-based tools from Antrhopic and OpenAI. - OR: the AI companies reach a plateau and beyond that they cannot make better models + the costs are too high. Models ship slower, AI companies raise prices, businesses need to rethink how to run their code and processes, and engineers getting rehired again.
I think AI fundamentally unlocks a lot more value in forcing smart people out of useless social media companies and into actually useful fields like robotics, bioengineering, space related fields and so on. Imagine if our brightest were working on new materials and fuels instead of marketing data pipelines.
Same with fan games, ROM hacks, mods, homebrew titles and recomps. AI has led to a huge flood of them to the point it's almost impossible to know what's human made or not anymore.
I suspect that's going to happen to every industry where programming plays even a minor role. Content Management Systems? There will be thousands of options available. Messaging tools? Thousands of options. Image editors, text editors, wiki software and office software? Again, thousands of options available.
The positive side is that anyone can compete with just about any company in any tech related industry. The negative side is that most of these people and companies will have no idea what they're doing, or give up and move on within a week or two.
Lots of industries will probably outright crash due to the flood of competition making supply outstrip demand a thousand to one, and a lot of unfortunate people and organisations will end up losing their work/livelihood/home/etc when the vibe-coded tools they attempt to use end up being full of bugs and oversights.
RIP anyone who puts their faith in tax audit software for instance.
An awful lot of software development houses and sub-industries are probably on the way out too. WordPress development agencies and other CMS specific outlets (like those focused on Shopify, Magento, Moodle, Drupal, etc) are going to find a larger and larger percentage of their customers asking AI to build or maintain their sites rather than them. The market for brochure and CRUD sites for small and medium sized businesses will probably crater.
The ability to use AI to replace a team with one or two people means the job market is probably getting even worse than it is now. AI is going to destroy the bottom 60-70% of programming jobs, and that percentage is only going up in future. Your choices are basically to either hope you can be in the top 10% or so of software engineers and make enough money to retire before things get truly dire, to hope you can start an SaaS company/do freelance work, or to find another line of work altogether.
It's probably not going to be any better for designers, writers or other office employees either.
But yeah, my prediction is that markets will get flooded with (often low-quality ) software, lots of existing companies and jobs will go away, and only the most technically skilled programmers will be hireable in the next decade.
i would like to see software engineers go after bigger ideas and projects, instead of the same old ideas (crud wrappers). software is not solved, in fact we're far from the limits we can push our software to