Show HN: Type Fighter 2
typefighter2.comFree, no account, and progress stays local. You can try on mobile, best with a physical keyboard.
Mario Teaches Typing was also a good one.
Then I built a split keyboard, and it turned out that was all I needed to learn to touch type in just two weeks. I wish I’d had one in the eighties.
I've got a background in pedagogy and I'm curious about the 'sequencing'.
- I think it's probably the right call to introduce letters incrementally
- I don't know whether teaching nonsense, rare combinations is the right start
The interesting educational questions for me are:
- which are the right letters to expose people to at the start?
- what's the right way to expose people to those letters?
e.g. some heuristics to consider off the top of my head:
1. look at common words in the English language
2. look at letters that occur frequently in those words
3. teach those letters
e.g. maybe `a` and `m` are plausible starters: `am`, `ma`, `mama`, `maam`, `ama` are not nonsense (vs `dj` or `fk` or whatever it was)
To motivate that more clearly:
- I'm a touch typer but I sometimes fumbled on e.g. 's;k;;l;;;;f;j` (to exaggerate) whereas when it starts being actual words, I fumbled far less on those.
- What this demonstrates is "being able to touch type in a way that's useful practically" is a different skill to "being able to touch type arbitrary character strings".
- i.e. I'm probably substantially slower at touch typing on very rare character combinations and that's almost certainly less useful for a novice to learn
(From a learner engagement perspective, it's also probably motivation-reinforcing when they're actual words as much as possible)
Great work though! I'm a bit of a 'sequencing' nerd when it comes to education; I think the core idea, theme + UIs etc are all very strong
I had this exact experience. typing `mam` and `mama` etc would've been a better start I think. I have no pedagogical background though.
I find it really weird we would propose learning anything but the "home" row of keys in the beginning. The whole exercise of high speed typing is having a solid orientation of the hands relative to the keyboard and returning to the home row seems pretty integral to that.
Teaching "a" and "m" without building the muscle memory of reseting to a known point seems like a recipe for disaster. You can type words better then those key combinations likely because you have already consolidated that mental process to something you don't think about.
Curious: (a) what % of people who touch type do you think did not learn through a specific formal programme based on a home row; (b) what % of those people do you think are 'disasters' at touch typing?
I think you could make a reasonable case that it's suboptimal to not start with the home row, and that the (a) % would be higher for starting with the home row. As I said, I think it's an interesting educational question: "which are the right letters to expose people to at the start?"
Would you be open to a suggestion that it's a bit black-and-white to say it's a "recipe for disaster" to do anything else?
I think that, empirically, since people do demonstrably learn touch-typing without a disciplined building block of "two keys on the home row as my foundation for everything", your hyperbole is somewhat off the mark -- but it's great that you feel passionate about this! I think it's highly valuable for people to be opinionated about the best way for people to learn, and I hope you channel that into helping others learn
[EDIT: to be clear, touch-typing is not an area I'm specifically passionate about the pedagogy of, and I was merely sharing some armchair musings with the OP. I'm a former maths teacher + software engineering coach, and I'm incredibly opinionated about certain sequencing decisions there, and I do genuinely think that's important]
The idea behind learning those letters is that you don't type words but a row of letters. A good typist makes no distinction in typing English, French, Portuguese or Dutch. They're just letters and they could form words, or not, shouldn't matter to a typist. Typing in DNA sequences should go as fast as your mother tongue.
I'm wondering: do you think there's a difference between being "a typist" and being "a knowledge worker with sufficiently good touch typing for your everyday purposes"?
I'd imagine that e.g. some professional nutritionists learn food health fundamentals in a different, deeper way to parents trying to prepare balanced meals for their children.
A tangible example of that: "5 fruit and veg a day" (as we have in the UK) probably isn't the most rigorous way to learn about nutrition, but it's simple and practical, and I think that can be the right trade-off to make to get parents to take positive steps forwards! I like to think about the counterfactuals: it's not always about the most theoretically globally optimal approach, sometimes it's just "What helps this person take a step forward, feel good about themselves, and be encouraged?"
Touch typing is a skill with a very low depth to its complexity by comparison. It's matching symbols to fingers, it's teaching motor neurons how to position hands the right way (I personally suspect that the few years I tried to learn how to play the piano, which started a bit before I was taught touch typing, helped me a ton), and… I think that's pretty much it.
I don't expect there's any advantage to be had from starting with "chunking" letters for touch typing. If anything that sounds like a premature optimization that harms more than it helps. Once the basics are covered it can probably help give speed boosts to fast typists because of faster processing speeds.
I think the piano is a very useful analogy, tbh.
Here's things we might consider when someone learns to play the piano:
- Help them play the simplest thing that sounds nice rather than arbitrary keys; that's motivating (analogy: recognisable words vs arbitrary strings)
- Help them learn patterns that have reusable valuable, e.g. scales and arpeggios, vs infrequent musical combinations (analogy: common letter patterns vs arbitrary combinations)
I agree that touch typing is not the same as being a trained nutritionist -- what I'm trying to gently suggest to the prior comment is that "Typing in DNA sequences should go as fast as your mother tongue" might perhaps be a black-and-white view of "what counts as touch-typing".
If I learned by ear and I can play "things that sound jazzy" in a skillful way, but I can't play discordant modern music by ear, maybe that doesn't matter! Maybe I don't need to be able to cover "any arbitrary piano note combination" as equally as possible -- maybe my end is "music that I enjoy playing", and maybe I've got sufficient things for those ends.
EDIT: I think your point on neurons is good, and it also makes me reflect on something else a bit peculiar about "Typing in DNA sequences should go as fast as your mother tongue" -- for this to hold, the person probably needs to be able to type arbitrary DNA sequences with the same regularity as their mother tongue...?
It seems both like the 'probable neuroscientific reality' as well as 'practically efficient trade-off' for us to have better wirings on "things we type more often" (and I guess it being an efficient trade-off is exaclty why our brains have evolved in that way)
I have watched my child run a similar program on his computer but with the incentives coming just after the home keys are learned, encouraging and rewarding sufficient speed, and yet eventually stop. It really comes down to external motivation.
These languages probably have different keyboard layouts. At least English and French do.
very obviously slopped together, none of the whimsy of, say, the typing of the dead
reminds me of those one-shot games i had to review for my ai evaluation work
Also, would be fun to see the actual leaderboards from everyone playing
I’m testing a change that keeps your score across keyboards, but that alone won't fix having to repeat the lessons. Which layout were you switching from and to?
I did think the start with `fjjf` etc was a little wonky- for me it felt like the game really took of once actual words were introduced. Very fun!
I’ll keep working on the game as time allows. It helps a lot to hear where things went wrong as well as the bits you enjoyed.
I would cut the part with random letters and instructions of where to put your fingers. People who touch type already have their own unconscious technique, and any generic advice will fall flat. And non touch typers will never play or enjoy this game, or if they do any advice given there is not what will teach them. The only thing any tutorial will achieve is to make people like me bounce off immediately. Go straight to words, and then start cranking up the difficulty.
I hunted and pecked this comment.
If you want, you can unlearn your custom fingerings (depending on how bad they are - for example if you only use 2-3 fingers on both hands, I'd recommend learning the 'proper' way).
You can see the same method followed on more traditional sites like typingclub.
So however suboptimal my technique is, it does not seem like a good use of time and effort to try to learn something that's allegedly better, as it already seems near the limit of what I would assume someone of my talent could reach, and because any gain would take a lot of effort and be incremental. I suspect that there are some diminishing returns, if I were a slow typer I would have more to gain, but I'm not.
So if that's the niche skill that the game is trying to teach me, that's fair, but I'd rather not learn it. And I generally find typing games fun otherwise.
not sure if the best way is to throw random letters at them? In languages and writing, there are certain pattern which occure far more often than others, so wouldnt it be better for learners to write "real" content?
Interestingly, and thankfully, I've avoided any form of RSI and I do attribute that largely to NOT confining myself to home row - but that's just an unverified anecdote.
Big same, n+1 anecdata from me too. I've always imagined it like sequential access to keys vs. random access... I need a key, I hit a key, it doesn't really matter from whence i need to reach it from. I also seem to hold mice at a 45º angle, so there's that too... not an RSI in sight, whew.
I agree with the other posts saying that the home-row first levels in this game feel wrong, no actual typing works like that, give me words.
I feel like AI-generated pixel art[0] is less noticeable than regular images... which upsets me, to be honest.
[0] through this metod, not just "make it pixel art" appended to the prompt.
I get my practice by typing out articles and books.